Benson Boone’s American Heart Album Review: A Promising Ride
Benson Boone’s second studio album, American Heart, arrives with the weight of expectation — a classic case of the “sophomore test” that has both elevated and crushed many promising artists. While his 2024 debut Fireworks & Rollerblades positioned him as a pop newcomer with viral hits and TikTok charm, American Heart album review attempts to solidify Boone’s standing as a serious, versatile artist with something more meaningful to say. And for the most part, he succeeds, even if he occasionally stumbles along the way.
At just 30 minutes in length, the 10-track album is tight, breezy, and radio-friendly — a deliberate move that keeps the energy flowing but leaves some emotional depth unexplored. Boone’s strongest asset remains his soaring, agile voice. He moves effortlessly between powerful belts and airy falsettos, recalling the vocal dexterity of Jason Mraz with a touch of modern pop polish. His performances are undeniably heartfelt, and even when the songwriting falters, his sincerity keeps things afloat.
A Tribute to Rock Icons — With a Pop Sheen
Boone has cited Bruce Springsteen as a major influence for this album, and that spirit is especially evident on the title track “American Heart,” a story-driven ballad placed at the very end of the album. Here, Boone recounts a harrowing real-life experience — a near-fatal car accident from his teenage years — with cinematic lyricism. However, the sound leans more toward the shimmering, synth-laced production of The Killers than the gritty, blue-collar Americana of The Boss. It’s Springsteen-inspired storytelling dressed in slick pop production, which might disappoint purists but feels like a natural progression for Boone.
Elsewhere, Boone pays homage to the glam and grandeur of rock’s golden eras. “Mr. Electric Blue” is a glittery nod to Electric Light Orchestra, complete with lush instrumentation and a heartfelt lyrical tribute to his father. It’s the kind of track that feels both nostalgic and contemporary, a balancing act Boone pulls off well.
His mother is lovingly honored in “Momma Song,” a delicate piano ballad that blooms into a full orchestral arrangement. The track features some of Boone’s most vulnerable lyrics to date: “Drive me through the country, tell me your story and you can play all of your favorite songs / ’cause I’m gonna need this when I’m holding pictures of you and that’s all I’ve got left.” The emotional weight might seem a bit heavy-handed for someone still in his early 20s, but Boone’s delivery is so sincere that it never comes across as inauthentic.
Commercial Confidence Meets Youthful Heart
If there were any doubts about Boone being a two-hit wonder after the breakout success of “Beautiful Things” and “Slow It Down,” American Heart lays those fears to rest. The album’s lead singles — particularly the infectious “Sorry I’m Here for Someone Else,” driven by propulsive drum loops — have kept Boone firmly planted on the charts, while his high-energy performances (and acrobatic backflips) continue to sell out arenas worldwide.
“Mystical Magical,” another standout, weaves a cheeky interpolation of Olivia Newton-John’s “Physical” into its chorus. It captures the vibrant ‘80s vibe that threads its way through much of the album, offering a fun and carefree contrast to the more serious moments.
Not every track hits the mark, however. “Reminds Me of You” tries for soulful introspection but lands as one of the weaker moments — a forgettable slice of toothless pop that borrows from the moody playbook of Olivia Rodrigo without her sharp lyrical edge. Thankfully, the rest of the album makes up for these lulls.
Also Read: Watch The Waterfront: New Drama by Dawson’s Creek Creator
Boone’s Secret Weapon: A Voice That Soars
One thing that sets Benson Boone apart from many of his chart-topping peers is his voice — pure, powerful, and remarkably nimble. On “Man in Me,” a mid-tempo bop, he shows off his full range, fluttering into high falsetto notes that would challenge even seasoned vocalists. It’s not just technical ability, though; Boone has a knack for imbuing his voice with emotion, making even the most formulaic lines feel fresh and personal.
What makes American Heart a successful follow-up isn’t just Boone’s vocal talent or his ear for melody — it’s his willingness to pay tribute to music’s past while carving out his own space in pop’s present. His decision to invite Queen legend Brian May onstage at Coachella earlier this year wasn’t just a stunt — it was a sign that Boone respects the greats and wants to bring that legacy into his own evolving sound.
American Heart Album Review:
In this American Heart Album Review, Benson Boone’s sophomore effort proves he’s more than a viral sensation. The album blends emotional depth with upbeat pop-rock energy, showcasing his impressive vocal range and evolving songwriting. With tracks inspired by legends like Bruce Springsteen and Electric Light Orchestra, Boone delivers a nostalgic yet fresh sound. While a few songs miss the mark, standout singles like “Sorry I’m Here for Someone Else” and “Mr. Electric Blue” highlight his growth. Overall, American Heart is a promising step forward in Boone’s rising music career.
Final Verdict: A Pop Star in Progress
American Heart may not be a perfect album — it wobbles in places, and some songs lack the bite needed to truly elevate the collection — but it’s a confident and often enjoyable ride from a young artist still finding his voice. Boone turns 23 just days after this album’s release, and there’s something refreshing about hearing an artist embrace both vulnerability and joy without trying to seem jaded or overly polished.
With his second album, Benson Boone proves he’s no flash in the pan. American Heart cements his status as one of pop’s most exciting young voices — not just because he can hit the high notes, but because he’s not afraid to wear his heart on his sleeve.
Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars
